
FamilyFans.com is a
non-commercial publication of Nappaland Communications Inc.
est. 1995
see also: nappalandliterary.com
It’s just a relaxing summer back in Radiator Springs when Lightning
McQueen (Owen Wilson) is challenged to a 3-course international race
supporting Allinol, sustainable energy. The gang from Radiator
Springs comes with him to Tokyo to act as his pit crew. But Mater’s
(Larry the Cable Guy) less than sophisticated habits leaves
Lightning cringing. After Mater causes Lightning to lose the first
race, they get in a fight and Mater packs his bags for home.
But meanwhile, Mater has been mistaken for an international spy, and
vital information has been passed to him making him indispensible to
British Intelligence. With the help of British Intelligence agents
Finn McMissile (Michael Caine) and Holly Shiftwell (Emily Mortimer),
he must foil the plot of an evil conglomerate seeking to sabotage
sustainable energy and kill Lightning McQueen.
When I first heard the plot of
Cars 2—Mater becomes an
international spy busting the bad guys—I thought, “Really?”
But I chose to give Pixar the benefit of the doubt because its Pixar
and if anyone could pull it off, they could. Unfortunately, in this
case they didn’t come through with their typical panache. Although
the visuals of Tokyo, Italy, and London are stunning, the
writing—usually Pixar’s strong point—leaves many things to be
desired.
The plot itself is contrived and not believable. Had Mater as
international spy been the plot of a 5-minute short or a
direct-to-DVD movie, it might have held its own. But for a
full-length Pixar film (and a painfully long one at that), it felt
forced and contrived. Because the first
Cars was very
relationship-driven, the filmmakers had to work to make cars seem
alive and likable. But in this sequel, the focus was action and no
time was given to character, leaving the two new characters, Finn
and Holly, as flat stereotypes.
The most enjoyable parts of the movie were the race scenes, a
departure from the main spy plot, which simply made the viewer wish
the writers had focused on the previous
Cars’ strengths. Instead,
the focus is on bumbling Mater being a bumbler, and this film won’t
be very enjoyable for those who don’t enjoy his bumbling.
But of course, I’m holding this movie to a much higher standard
because it is Pixar. But even recent movies from other makers such
as DreamWorks (Kung Fu Panda
2 and How to Train Your
Dragon) definitely have this movie beat. Kids will probably
watch the movie and just think it’s a fun, fast action movie. But
parents, who have come to expect entertainment that everyone in the
family can enjoy and even savor, will be disappointed.
Use these questions to spark discussion among family members who are interested in this movie:
• Lightning was embarrassed by his best friend, Mater, and treated
him badly because of it. Have you ever treated your friend less than
friendly because they embarrassed you?
• How could you have responded better?
• Mater realized that people thought of him as an idiot, but
ultimately decided to still just be himself. Is there something
about yourself that you try to hide or change because you’re worried
people won’t like you?
• What do you think would be a better solution than trying to be
someone you’re not?
--AV
Note: All product-related graphics in this article are standard publicity/promotional shots and are owned by their respective publisher.