Holes

 

review by

Amy Nappa


HOLES by Louis Sachar

(Yearling/Random House)

Best for: Ages 10 and up

READ...

Camp Green Lake isn’t a camp. 

There’s not much there that's green; the lake has long been dried up; water is rationed; and only rattlesnakes, scorpions, and poisonous lizard survive. 

"Camp" Green Lake is a detention center for boys. A prison.

When Stanley Yelnats (yes, that’s a palindrome) is convicted of a crime he didn’t commit, he’s sent to Camp Green Lake. There he’s assigned to a tent and informed that he’s required to dig one hole each day. A hole that’s five feet deep and five feet wide. If he finds anything of interest in that hole, he’s to immediately report his findings to the Warden, a cruel woman who paints her fingernails with rattlesnake venom. Which leads Stanley to wonder…what’s the Warden looking for?

In spite of the despairing conditions, Holes is a story about hope, redemption, and what it means to be a true friend. Stanley, like many of us, wants to do the right thing, and often knows what the right thing to do is—but he’s intimidated by others and by his own fears. He blames his problems on his “no-good-dirty-rotten-pig-stealing great-great-grandfather” whose actions many years ago resulted in a curse being put on the Yelnats family. So, initially, Stanley accepts his lot in life as a loser. But the predicaments he finds himself in at Camp Green Lake finally force Stanley to stand up for himself and for what’s right.

This is a delightful story for families to read aloud and discuss along the way. Author Louis Sachar weaves in stories about Stanley’s great-great-grandfather, a western bandit named Kissin’ Kate Barlow, and a racially charged situation that occurred when water still was abundant at Green Lake. These stories blend together as the plot progresses, and make for a surprising and exciting ending to Holes.

The humor in this story is dark, and some of the situations Stanley finds himself in may be frightening for young children, but overall this is a wonderful book for children (and their parents who won’t want to put it down!). It’s won numerous prestigious awards, including the Newbery Medal, which is awarded annually by the American Library Association, and recognizes the most distinguished children’s book of that year.

Holes reminds us of the sacrifices true friends make for each other, the difference on person can make by his or her choices and actions, and the legacy parents leave for their children.

Note of interest—Holes has been made into a movie that will release this spring. Hopefully the movie will match the quality of the book.  

THINK...

• Stanley’s entire family feels they are doomed by a curse that’s been passed down from generation to generation, and the Warden and Zero also suffer from what’s been passed to them from their parents. What do you think has been passed to you by the generations before you? What do you plan to pass on to the generations that follow you? How are you making that happen right now?

• Think about the story of Katherine and Sam. Do you think the actions of the townspeople were right or wrong? Explain your answer. What do you think of the choices Katherine made after the tragedy occurred? What would have been a better choice for her to make? How do anger and a desire for revenge hurt people?

• Stanley and Zero seem to be unlikely friends, yet in the end their friendship is what brings redemption for many people. Who are people that seem to be unlikely friends for you? What great things might happen if you chose to reach out and befriend these people?

• If Jesus had been at Camp Green Lake, what difference do you think he would have made? If he’d been accused of a crime he didn’t commit and sent there as Stanley was, what choices do you think he would have made? What about you? Would your actions have been like Stanley’s? Like one of the counselors? Or would they be entirely different?

LIVE!

1 John 3:16-20 says,

This is how we know what love is: Jesus Christ laid down his life for us. And we ought to lay down our lives for our brothers. If anyone has material possessions and sees his brother in need but has no pity on him, how can the love of God be in him? Dear children, let us not love with words or tongue but with actions and in truth. This then is how we know that we belong to the truth, and how we set our hearts at rest in his presence whenever our hearts condemn us. For God is greater than our hearts, and he knows everything.” (NIV)

Consider how these words relate to the friendship of Stanley and Zero. Then consider how they relate to your own relationships. Are you loving with the love of Jesus? Are you loving with actions as well as with words? Let this passage challenge you in the coming days and weeks.

If you liked HOLES, you might also enjoy: 

The View from Saturday by E. L. Konigsburg (Simon & Schuster)

This Newbery Medal winning book by Konigsburg (who also won this award for From the Mixed-Up Files of Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler) focuses on unlikely friendships. Four smart and funny sixth-graders and their teacher are joined by unusual circumstances and become the stars of their school’s Academic Bowl. Beyond their ability to work as a savvy and brainy team these kids choose to become friends and meet each Saturday for tea. The View from Saturday, as with Holes, shows what can happen when we choose friends who seem to be different from us, and how these friendships can make lasting differences.
The Veritas Project 2: Nightmare Academy by Frank Peretti (Tommy Nelson)

Teen twins, Elisha and Elijah Springfield, along with their parents, are part of a top-secret project to investigate strange events and situations. While undercover, tracking the mysterious disappearance of two runaways, Elisha and Elijah are kidnapped and end up in a prison-like school where their guards/teachers try to fill their minds with new ideas about Truth. This story considers what the world would be like without right or wrong, without God and truth. It’s a thrilling adventure that underscores the importance of making the right choices in our beliefs about God and his power.

 

###

Amy Nappa is a best-selling and award-winning author of many books, including A Woman's Touch and The Low-Fat Lifestyle. She's also a veteran movie critic and associate publisher of FAMILYFANS.com